Click here to Skip to main content
15,919,245 members

Bugs and Suggestions

   

General discussions, site bug reports and suggestions about the site.

For general questions check out the CodeProject FAQs. To report spam and abuse Head to the Spam and abuse watch. If you wish to report a bug privately, especially those related to security, please email webmaster@codeproject.com

 
Generalsatellite to refresh forum tables Pin
toxcct11-May-04 10:45
toxcct11-May-04 10:45 
GeneralRe: satellite to refresh forum tables Pin
toxcct12-May-04 8:51
toxcct12-May-04 8:51 
GeneralRe: satellite to refresh forum tables Pin
Maximilien12-May-04 9:07
Maximilien12-May-04 9:07 
GeneralRe: satellite to refresh forum tables Pin
toxcct12-May-04 9:09
toxcct12-May-04 9:09 
GeneralRe: satellite to refresh forum tables Pin
Maximilien12-May-04 10:17
Maximilien12-May-04 10:17 
GeneralRe: satellite to refresh forum tables Pin
toxcct12-May-04 10:23
toxcct12-May-04 10:23 
GeneralRe: satellite to refresh forum tables Pin
Heath Stewart13-May-04 11:55
protectorHeath Stewart13-May-04 11:55 
GeneralCP Wiki Pin
Jeff Varszegi11-May-04 6:18
professionalJeff Varszegi11-May-04 6:18 
There's a lot of great content here, with more arriving each day. I see two forces:

1) It's desirable that the articles be able to be browsed as a web, but right now it's rare for authors to link to other articles in their own. Hence, if you browse the CP article-web you won't get far.

2) The best way of currently finding articles on a concept is to browse the article categories. I'm not saying that we should do away with the categories-- we really can't. However, drilling down into categories this way doesn't let you read an abstract of a concept, with links to helpful articles in the middle that explain facets of the topic, and links to related concepts at the bottom. I'm positive that there's a Wiki tool out there that would allow CP to serve CP-branded Wiki content with minimal modification.

I really like Wikipedia. It's the closest thing to a decent FAQ for the world's knowledge that I've seen. However, it isn't focused on Windows and .NET, and it doesn't keep people on this site. A Wiki focused on Windows and .NET, backed up by great articles from the site, would increase the ease of navigation of the articles, decrease the number of stupid questions if presented as a FAQ in the right places, and be of more interest and use to the CP community in general. Also, it would allow serving more ad impressions if desirable.

Wikis don't have to be editable by anonymous people, and I wouldn't advocate that for this either; in particular I wouldn't want someone to be able to delete content from someone else. I thought through a few options:

1) Let only those of a certain rank edit the Wiki
- Discarded, since it's too easy to achieve high rank; witness Daniel Stephen Rule and his accursed chatbots. The only rank I'd use this way would be platinum, but to set the bar this high would be to reject the contributions of people who don't have the time to write 25 articles.

2) Grant certain decent people the right to edit the Wiki, without being full editors of the site
- Pros: gives some people more personal stake in the site, pools greater talent and experience for the Wiki, and allows for a much larger volume of input, while inherently filtering spam; if someone abuses their role, just undo the badness and remove their access, something which might never have to happen

3) Let the current editors edit the Wiki
- Pros: complete control over content probably guarantees highest quality
- Cons: less grassroots power, smaller Wiki

4) Let the current editors edit the Wiki, and approve content that could be submitted by anyone
- Pros: complete control, bigger Wiki, gives people the chance to contribute in an easier way than writing articles
- Cons: increases the load on editors, even though approving a well-written entry or change wouldn't take long; also would possibly require more integration work to make it work smoothly with the Code Project website


Just some thoughts I've been having for a couple of weeks now.

[EDIT] Submissions in #4 could easily be implemented with a simple form that would send email to a special address or just dump the content into a table. The editor could then copy and paste the content into the Wiki using his/her normal access, making slight modifications if necessary. [/EDIT]


-Jeff

here, bloggy bloggy
GeneralMy Blog Pin
Michael P Butler11-May-04 2:41
Michael P Butler11-May-04 2:41 
GeneralRe: My Blog Pin
Chris Maunder11-May-04 5:46
cofounderChris Maunder11-May-04 5:46 
GeneralRe: My Blog Pin
Michael P Butler11-May-04 5:50
Michael P Butler11-May-04 5:50 
GeneralRe: My Blog Pin
Chris Meech11-May-04 9:37
Chris Meech11-May-04 9:37 
GeneralRe: My Blog Pin
toxcct11-May-04 10:36
toxcct11-May-04 10:36 
GeneralBug in New ToolBar Pin
Mazdak10-May-04 23:45
Mazdak10-May-04 23:45 
GeneralRe: Bug in New ToolBar Pin
toxcct11-May-04 2:25
toxcct11-May-04 2:25 
GeneralRe: Bug in New ToolBar Pin
Michael P Butler11-May-04 2:38
Michael P Butler11-May-04 2:38 
GeneralRe: Bug in New ToolBar Pin
Mazdak11-May-04 10:46
Mazdak11-May-04 10:46 
GeneralSheeesh! Pin
Roger Allen10-May-04 4:15
Roger Allen10-May-04 4:15 
GeneralRe: Sheeesh! Pin
Tim Deveaux10-May-04 6:30
Tim Deveaux10-May-04 6:30 
GeneralRe: Sheeesh! Pin
Roger Allen10-May-04 6:44
Roger Allen10-May-04 6:44 
GeneralRe: Sheeesh! Pin
Tim Deveaux10-May-04 8:04
Tim Deveaux10-May-04 8:04 
GeneralArticle forum RSS feed Pin
Paul Watson8-May-04 11:30
sitebuilderPaul Watson8-May-04 11:30 
GeneralI18N Pin
soundman326-May-04 5:09
soundman326-May-04 5:09 
GeneralRe: I18N Pin
Colin Angus Mackay10-May-04 11:00
Colin Angus Mackay10-May-04 11:00 
GeneralInstructions to implement projects written on this site Pin
Salam Y. ELIAS4-May-04 9:30
professionalSalam Y. ELIAS4-May-04 9:30 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.