|
Jason Henderson wrote:
CP2 appears to be dying before it even starts if I interpret correctly the lack of enthusiasm lately. Let's hope that is not the case. Anyway...
Well, I lost almost all my interest on it, and I hope that my critics below will be interpreted as suggestions for improvement, although I only point what I consider errors, not provide solutions.
1. The winning projects were:
a. Yet another UI library. Even taking in account its cool name (I love it, BTW), how much interest will this raise?
b. Yet another bug tracking tool. Do we need one?
c. Yet another Application Framework. As much as I like the great Marc’s articles about AAL, I doubt there will be lots of people interested on working on this project, because I believe that only experience programmers appreciate the real beauty of AA. Most programmers will stay with the “big guys” frameworks.
400,000 people and all we got was this?? Come on, people, I know that we are much better than this!
2. This is all going too fast. About a week or two ago, no one have ever heard of CP2. Now, luckily, 1% or 2% of all CPians have heard of it. The symptoms: only 30 or so people bothered to vote on the winning project. A mouse click. How many people will want to put hard work on it?
Kant wrote:
Actually she replied back to me "You shouldn't fix the bug. You should kill it"
|
|
|
|
|
I tend to agree with your criticisms, and yet I'm really surprised at the three project winners. Certainly not my first three choices. But I'm certainly willing to participate, at a minimum for the learning experience.
Daniel Turini wrote:
As much as I like the great Marc’s articles about AAL, I doubt there will be lots of people interested on working on this project
For the record (which I stated somewhere else a bit more obtusely), I definitely wasn't planning on ramming this down anyone's throat. On the contrary--I wanted to gather ideas from the team members and let the concept have a life of its own, separate from the AAL. Personally, I'd prefer to keep the AAL itself under my sole development direction for the time being, although I would have no problems with people pillaging ideas and code from it.
Daniel Turini wrote:
This is all going too fast.
Perhaps. There seemed to be a lot of enthusiasm, and you got to go with that. It may also have to do with moving off of the lounge, where things are a lot more visible.
I too am very curious about the perceived lack of interest. Maybe everyone is just trying to get some work done today. I know I sure as heck am!
Marc
Help! I'm an AI running around in someone's f*cked up universe simulator.
Sensitivity and ethnic diversity means celebrating difference, not hiding from it. - Christian Graus
Every line of code is a liability - Taka Muraoka
Microsoft deliberately adds arbitrary layers of complexity to make it difficult to deliver Windows features on non-Windows platforms--Microsoft's "Halloween files"
|
|
|
|
|
1) What project idea were you interested in?
2) Too slow = no interest. Look at the outline i provided and tell me its not a going to take a while to even get started. 
If it comes down to 10 people per project, then it will be more easily managed than 20 or 30. Anyway, if one project dies, maybe we can start one up that's better and hopefully learn from our mistakes.
thanks for the critique
Jason Henderson My articles
"The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter." - Winston Churchill
|
|
|
|
|
Jason Henderson wrote:
What project idea were you interested in?
Actually, anything that hasn't being done before. It doesn't matter if it is an AI project, a game, a P2P, anything that doesn't reinvent the wheel, unless you are about to create the ultimate wheel. Everytime I see another UI library, I question myself, trying to understand the people who are writing it: do they really need another UI library, or is it just a waste of effort?
That's why I mentioned AAL on my original post: on the three winning projects, it's where you can create some really new things.
Kant wrote:
Actually she replied back to me "You shouldn't fix the bug. You should kill it"
|
|
|
|
|
What I'm most interested in for a UI library is the unusual controls/components. 
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
jdunlap wrote:
What I'm most interested in for a UI library is the unusual controls/components.
I've been looking for some innovation in this area for quite a while now. Sadly, I can't think of any good ideas myself! I wonder if I'll still be alive when true 3D displays are created. I think 90% of the problem is that there's only so much you can do in 2D. And personally, I don't buy into skins. It's like when my girlfriend gets a haircut. For a short while, it's like sleeping with a different woman.
Marc
Help! I'm an AI running around in someone's f*cked up universe simulator.
Sensitivity and ethnic diversity means celebrating difference, not hiding from it. - Christian Graus
Every line of code is a liability - Taka Muraoka
Microsoft deliberately adds arbitrary layers of complexity to make it difficult to deliver Windows features on non-Windows platforms--Microsoft's "Halloween files"
|
|
|
|
|
scrollable viewport
monthview
ruler
commandbar
treelistview (DONE)
listbar (outlook-style) (DONE)
toolbox listbar (DONE)
clock (DONE)
dial
range picker (been done, but not to my satisfaction)
skinnable popup - for balloons, etc.
data navbar (been done, but not to my satisfaction)
collapsible panel (DONE)
color picker bar - functionality is like scrollbar
color palette
color picker gradient - round, square, etc
auto-complete textbox (DONE?)
image-calendar
time-scheduler (DONE?)
topiclist
imagelistview
appbar
wizard ctl
advanced message box
analog meter control (been done, but not to my satisfaction)
peak-meter
number ticker (like odometer) (DONE?)
colorcombo
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
Cool! Some interesting things in there!
Marc
Help! I'm an AI running around in someone's f*cked up universe simulator.
Sensitivity and ethnic diversity means celebrating difference, not hiding from it. - Christian Graus
Every line of code is a liability - Taka Muraoka
Microsoft deliberately adds arbitrary layers of complexity to make it difficult to deliver Windows features on non-Windows platforms--Microsoft's "Halloween files"
|
|
|
|
|
To be honest, i don't expect most of these first projects to be terribly adventurous, or to run strong all that long (though hopefully they will run long enough to produce some useful stuff). They will, however, pave the way for more exciting projects later on...
I'm eagerly awaiting the completion of all this housekeeping work, so the team(s) can get down to some serious discussions and design work. For my part, i'd love to see a UI library (or app framework) build on something already available, such as WTL or VCF - filling in the cracks, so to speak, and fleshing them out.
The advantage of a library, after all, is that it reduces or eliminates the integration cost otherwise associated with working someone else's code into your app. Rather than spending time trying to decide which of the grid/menu/tooltip classes out there you should use, you go with the one that's already been tested and integrated with the rest of your GUI.
Not too extreme, no, but something that wouldn't hurt either, given the number of free controls, etc. on CP.
Shog9
So much he don't understand,
Just might never make it to a man...
|
|
|
|
|
Every time I download a control from here, there is always some surprise and it can take alot of time to figure out what's wrong. The first thing being that they don't compile. For us people doing other things than programming it is a pain in the ass. Why not do a library that is free, tested and can be used by every idiot(don't look at me.. they are out there )
jhaga
|
|
|
|
|
Anonymous wrote:
Every time I download a control from here, there is always some surprise and it can take alot of time to figure out what's wrong. The first thing being that they don't compile. For us people doing other things than programming it is a pain. Why not do a library that is free, tested and can be used by every idiot(don't look at me.. they are out there)
Exactly!
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
Why did you edit "pain in the ass"? We are not in the Lounge
jhaga
CodeProject House, Paul Watson wrote:
...and the roar of John Simmons own personal Nascar in the garage. Meg flitting about taking photos.Chris having an heated arguement with Colin Davies and .S.Rod. over egian values. Nish manically typing *censur*. Duncan racing around after his pet *c.* Michael Martin and Bryce loudly yelling *c.* C.G. having a fit as Roger Wright loads up *c.* . Anna waving her *c.* and Deb scoffing chocolates in the corner.
...Good heavens!
|
|
|
|
|
Why do you think it's such a big deal that I did so? 
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
Just stay off my ass! Hehe, I guess I have been talking to John and his language is catching on.
jhaga
CodeProject House, Paul Watson wrote:
...and the roar of John Simmons own personal Nascar in the garage. Meg flitting about taking photos.Chris having an heated arguement with Colin Davies and .S.Rod. over egian values. Nish manically typing *censur*. Duncan racing around after his pet *c.* Michael Martin and Bryce loudly yelling *c.* C.G. having a fit as Roger Wright loads up *c.* . Anna waving her *c.* and Deb scoffing chocolates in the corner.
...Good heavens!
|
|
|
|
|
Jason Henderson wrote:
CP2 appears to be dying before it even starts if I interpret correctly the lack of enthusiasm lately.
 I sure hope not.
Thanks for listing out the project phases, Jason.
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
Jason Henderson wrote:
CP2 appears to be dying before it even starts if I interpret correctly the lack of enthusiasm lately. Let's hope that is not the case. Anyway...
I don't think so...
The reason I think too many messages posted in span of 3 or 4 days. It makes difficult to read those many messages and sometimes CP hiccups.
People like me who spend 1 hour or 2 hours a day on CP, it's very difficult to read all the messages and reply back to them.
My suggestions:
1. What we need is a CP Wiki board exclusive for Collaboration board? (with no advertisements and Expanded view)
or
2. Daily Digest of all the messages posted in the Collaboration board mailed to participating members?
Never take a problem to your boss unless you have a solution.
This signature was created by "Code Project Quoter".
|
|
|
|
|
But we also need a message board where we can talk about the projects and joke around(you know those bad jokes that Paul usually tells )
jhaga
CodeProject House, Paul Watson wrote:
...and the roar of John Simmons own personal Nascar in the garage. Meg flitting about taking photos.Chris having an heated arguement with Colin Davies and .S.Rod. over egian values. Nish manically typing *censur*. Duncan racing around after his pet *c.* Michael Martin and Bryce loudly yelling *c.* C.G. having a fit as Roger Wright loads up *c.* . Anna waving her *c.* and Deb scoffing chocolates in the corner.
...Good heavens!
|
|
|
|
|
Kant wrote:
1. What we need is a CP Wiki board exclusive for Collaboration board? (with no advertisements and Expanded view)
or
2. Daily Digest of all the messages posted in the Collaboration board mailed to participating members?
Which were both parts of the unselected Code Project Tools project...
John
"We want to be alone when we hear too many words and we feel alone when it has been a while since anyone has spoken to us." Paul David Tripp -- War of Words
|
|
|
|
|
Personally, I think it's a good idea.
Maybe you could help Chris out with it, though.
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
Jason Henderson wrote:
but Paul Watson was also nominated. Paul, any thoughts? Are you interested? If not, Anders will be declared the PL.
Oh hey I was nominated. To be honest though I think Anders should be the guy (his idea.) If PMS, the ASP.NET Web Control Library or the Code Snippet projects get voted sometime then I will happily lead if nominated for them.
I want to only lead something I am really interested in, otherwise I will be a bad leader for not having much passion for the idea.
I am willing to work on the Defect Tracker project though as it is definitley a part of the PMS idea as far as I think.
Can't wait for work to begin guys, it should be an experience to remember whatever the outcome
Paul Watson
Bluegrass
Cape Town, South Africa
Chris Losinger wrote:
i hate needles so much i can't even imagine allowing one near The Little Programmer
|
|
|
|
|
Anders Molin is the official PL for the Defect Tracking system. Congrats Anders!
Jason Henderson My articles
"The best argument against democracy is a five-minute conversation with the average voter." - Winston Churchill
|
|
|
|
|
Congrats! Anders, I have confidence that you'll do a good job. 
"Blessed are the peacemakers, for they shall be called sons of God." - Jesus
"You must be the change you wish to see in the world." - Mahatma Gandhi
|
|
|
|
|
Thanks
- Anders
Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
|
|
|
|
|
Wow, I just leave CP for a couple of hours, and get beck to about 40 new messages about CPP 
Jason Henderson wrote:
Anders Molin is the official PL for the Defect Tracking system
Thanks
The original idea was a Defect Tracking and a Source Versionering tool (Like Source Safe or CVS), and make them work together....
What has happened with that?
Are we still going to make both parts?
- Anders
Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
|
|
|
|
|
Like Marc, I would also like the teams to be established before we make the design documents for the project. I think it would be a good idea if there is a couple of persons working on those.
Anyone interested in helping me with all the writing?
I mean, English is not my native language, and I'm not the best writer in the world...
- Anders
Money talks, but all mine ever says is "Goodbye!"
|
|
|
|
General 
News 
Suggestion 
Question 
Bug 
Answer 
Joke 
Praise 
Rant 
Admin 
Submit an article or tip
