Click here to Skip to main content
15,868,016 members

Survey Results

Do you feel Artificial Intelligence should be regulated?

Survey period: 10 Oct 2022 to 17 Oct 2022

Because regulation around software development has generally solved the problems they were designed to solve, right?

OptionVotes% 
Yes - we need to ensure we protect ourselves and society before it's too late15423.58
Yes - if it's not just pointless paperwork and is actually effective12619.30
Yes - if it doesn't stifle innovation or add any burden to general AI developers375.67
Yes - for other reasons192.91
I don't know.8012.25
No, it just stifles innovation and generates pointless paperwork355.36
No - we're already protected by sufficient regulations. New ones are just noise182.76
No - there's no point unless every government agrees and fully enforces the rules, which won't happen9214.09
No - for other reasons263.98
I don't care.6610.11



 
GeneralNo... here's why Pin
charlieg15-Oct-22 5:54
charlieg15-Oct-22 5:54 
GeneralZero Pin
Bruce Patin12-Oct-22 6:10
Bruce Patin12-Oct-22 6:10 
GeneralRe: Zero Pin
trønderen12-Oct-22 9:43
trønderen12-Oct-22 9:43 
GeneralYes - but not yet Pin
Rick York11-Oct-22 7:20
mveRick York11-Oct-22 7:20 
GeneralRe: Yes - but not yet Pin
Pete Lomax Member 1066450511-Oct-22 10:04
professionalPete Lomax Member 1066450511-Oct-22 10:04 
GeneralRe: Yes - but not yet Pin
trønderen11-Oct-22 10:46
trønderen11-Oct-22 10:46 
GeneralHinge to hang hellbent AI Pin
jochance11-Oct-22 6:46
jochance11-Oct-22 6:46 
GeneralRe: Hinge to hang hellbent AI Pin
trønderen11-Oct-22 10:49
trønderen11-Oct-22 10:49 
GeneralWe need to be embedding our AIs with human empathy Pin
obermd11-Oct-22 4:35
obermd11-Oct-22 4:35 
The only way to ensure AI values humans is to embed it with human empathy. For decades, science fiction writers, going all the way back to Mary Shelly's Frankenstein and possibly even before then, have grokked this simple fact. Isaac Asimov attempted to codify this in his Three Laws of Robotics. In fiction those AIs with human empathy supported humans and those without it conquered and ruled humans.

Looking at the real world, Microsoft Tay had to be shut down because it didn't have human empathy embedded and was allowed to learn from the worst of humanity - Facebook and Twitter. Other generalized AIs, as opposed to subject matter expert AIs, have also fared poorly because they don't have empathy. We've yet to see the results of embedding human empathy into an AI.

GeneralI Don't Know Pin
CodeZombie6211-Oct-22 2:19
CodeZombie6211-Oct-22 2:19 
Generalmisleading terminologies - Machine Learning > AI Pin
maze311-Oct-22 0:28
professionalmaze311-Oct-22 0:28 
GeneralShouldn't AI be given the opportunity to regulate itself? PinPopular
Marc Clifton10-Oct-22 12:55
mvaMarc Clifton10-Oct-22 12:55 
GeneralRe: Shouldn't AI be given the opportunity to regulate itself? Pin
trønderen10-Oct-22 14:29
trønderen10-Oct-22 14:29 
GeneralRe: Shouldn't AI be given the opportunity to regulate itself? Pin
Sander Rossel10-Oct-22 21:23
professionalSander Rossel10-Oct-22 21:23 
GeneralThe question cannot be answered without AI techniques Pin
trønderen10-Oct-22 8:22
trønderen10-Oct-22 8:22 
GeneralNo, for other reasons Pin
Greg Utas10-Oct-22 4:30
professionalGreg Utas10-Oct-22 4:30 
GeneralRe: No, for other reasons Pin
GKP199210-Oct-22 18:39
professionalGKP199210-Oct-22 18:39 
GeneralRe: No, for other reasons Pin
scott mcnulty 202111-Oct-22 7:25
scott mcnulty 202111-Oct-22 7:25 
GeneralYes. Pin
Ron Anders10-Oct-22 3:37
Ron Anders10-Oct-22 3:37 
GeneralHad to be done... Pin
CHill6010-Oct-22 3:30
mveCHill6010-Oct-22 3:30 
GeneralBefore you regulate it, define it Pin
Sander Rossel9-Oct-22 23:40
professionalSander Rossel9-Oct-22 23:40 
GeneralRe: Before you regulate it, define it Pin
trønderen10-Oct-22 8:50
trønderen10-Oct-22 8:50 
GeneralRe: Before you regulate it, define it Pin
maze311-Oct-22 0:34
professionalmaze311-Oct-22 0:34 
GeneralAI is just tossing a very large dice on a big set of data Pin
den2k889-Oct-22 22:17
professionalden2k889-Oct-22 22:17 
GeneralMore important: regulate use of AI Pin
Bernhard Hiller9-Oct-22 21:04
Bernhard Hiller9-Oct-22 21:04 

General General    News News    Suggestion Suggestion    Question Question    Bug Bug    Answer Answer    Joke Joke    Praise Praise    Rant Rant    Admin Admin   

Use Ctrl+Left/Right to switch messages, Ctrl+Up/Down to switch threads, Ctrl+Shift+Left/Right to switch pages.